This is a public Blog  publicRSS

Entry

    Sorry, Your Majesty, for the Mess We're In
    Entry posted 7/28/09 by dcrockerElite Contributor
    5027 Views, 6 Comments
    Title:
    Sorry, Your Majesty, for the Mess We're In
    Entry:

    Let me first say that I'm not British, and any news about the UK's adulation of the royal family strikes me as outdated and silly. While I was on vacation with my slightly dysfunctional family last week, a group of "emminent" economists in merry old England issued a formal apology to Queen Elizabeth II for failing to predict the financial crisis. It was their response to her "demand" nine months earlier at the London School of Economics to know why no one was able to predict the crash.

    Call me childish, but reading this conjured up images of the old Monty Python movies my brother forced me to watch growing up...the bumbling men in fancy dress falling over each other and quaking in fear as they went before royalty.

    Image:
    More:

    According to the letter of apology, "In summary, your majesty, the failure to foresee the timing, extent and severity of the crisis and to head it off, while it had many causes, was principally a failure of the collective imagination of many bright people, both in this country and internationally, to understand the risks to the system as a whole." Don't we know this already? Is this really news in July 2009?

    There are plenty of well-researched pieces on the risk management failures that led to the mess we're in. I caught up on old Vanity Fairs last week with meaty pieces on the likes of AIG, Goldman Sachs and other worthy scapegoats who threw risk management to the winds in their pursuit of profit. There's plenty of blame to go around that goes way beyond the best economic minds in the world. And, if the world's leading economics can't accurately forecast the market, then what hope do the rest of us have in doing our FY10 forecasts for Phase I ESA volume? 

    [I mean no disrespect to any UK readers out there, and blame John Cleese. If I've offended anyone, let me know and I will promptly (i.e., within 9 months) issue a formal letter of apology and cc her majesty.]

    Next up: my recap of 2Q09 Phase I ESA market results, and perhaps a word on my forecast with a long list of caveats!

    Keywords:
    financial crisis, economists, forecast

    Comments

    • posted 7/28/09 by AmyHSuper Contributor

      Dianne,

      Your post cracked me up and reminded me of all the flack Mrs. Obama got (or was it the President himself) for actually touching the queen. I don't understand the public's fascination with Paris Hilton, but I guess I can understand the immense interest in the royal family, although I don't follow them myself. (I don't care about the Kennedy's either.)

      If I had that kind of pull, I'd demand an apology for the financial crisis too. I'd love someone to grovel on their knees while explaining to me why my portfolio is down 50% and my kids' college savings would barely pay for summer camp. Sign me up!

      I think Monty Python skits are far more entertaining than the exploits of William and Harry.

      Reply to this Comment

    • posted 7/28/09 by DSopchakNewbie

      Since Goldman Sachs is making so much profit from the lack of competition, and the goverment has the right to buy part of the company, why doesn't it do that, and take part of the profit? 

      Reply to this Comment

    • posted 7/29/09 by GFredNewbie

      Thanks Ms. Maven

      ... sadly, no such apologies for us wee US taxpayers ...  But our Mr. Geithner has run some stress tests on our system and since our top 20 banks only need another $ 80 Bn to stabilize, pronounced that it's all ... (in his best Monty Python impression):

      just a flesh wound!

      Reply to this Comment