Topic

    pkennedy
    Phase One on a known Brownfield site?
    Topic posted May 4, 2010 by pkennedyMember, last edited January 19, 2012
    617 Views, 9 Comments
    Title:
    Phase One on a known Brownfield site?

    Comment

    • ZekeF
      posted May 5, 2010 by ZekeFContributor

      Whats the question?  Is this for a specific site or just an "in general" question?

      You might get more of a response if you provide a little more detail and specify what questions you have or what you'd like discussed. 

    • pkennedy
      posted May 5, 2010 by pkennedyMember

      If a site has been defined as a Brownfield site in the past, what would be the purpose of now performing a Phase I on the site?

    • Cory
      posted May 5, 2010 by CoryContributor

      Ss and Gs

    • ZekeF
      posted May 5, 2010 by ZekeFContributor

      I can think of a few reasons a Phase I would be warranted.  Has any cleanup been conducted?  Is contamination still present? Are there other potential sources of contamination at the site?  A Phase I could assist with answering some of these questions.

      Also, a Phase I would likely be a started point for liability protection or insurance.  It also might assist with a new users evaulation of the business risk associated with the site.  If theres financing, a Phase I may be required by the lender.

      To sum up, Phase Is are oftened performed on sites already identifed as brownfields for a whole list of reasons.  Of course, a Phase I might not be warranted for a new user depending on their needs.  It would be something that would have to be evaulated at a case by case basis. 

    • pkennedy
      posted May 5, 2010 by pkennedyMember

      Thank you for the input.  You've provided me with a useful perspective.

    • Scott J. Dahlgren
      posted May 5, 2010 by Scott J. DahlgrenContributor

      In addition, the Phase I ESA might identify if there are any off-site issues that may have impacted the subject property.  That is the most common answer I give as to why to do a Phase I ESA on a property like this...yes, there may be on-site issues you know about, but there may also be off-site issues that you were not aware of...

    • Tom Speight
      posted May 5, 2010 by Tom SpeightElite Contributor

      It's also a pretty convenient way to summarize info about the place, even if you're not using it for AAI purposes.  It'd be easier for an investor to commission a Phase I than to wrestle with all the state and federal records themselves.

    • Stones
      posted May 6, 2010 by StonesContributor

      Possibly for bona fide prospective purchaser liability protection.

    • dezovski
      posted May 9, 2010 by dezovskiSuper Contributor

      Let's not forget that AAI was developed as part of the Brownfield Redevelopment Act...so obviously EPA felt it was critical to do Phase I reports on Brownfields to maintain liability protections....this is how you would quantify the issues on the site while maintaining your liability protections.